Hows the great gatsby movie 1974 compared to the book. Surprisingly, there were some facts that were left out, that in my opinion were critical for the story and the symbolism on it. Scott fitzgeralds great gatsby was always fighting an uphill battle, but leonardo dicaprio, carey mulligan, and. It is an intricate story that entails an enormous amount of meaning and significance to society, but the literary version is not one that is capable of being adapted into a film that can capture the entire effect, because so much of the quality of the great gatsby. Both works explore the societal concept of the american dream. There are a few instances of violence that show blood, including a lot of blood spreading in water. The great gatsby is a standout novel that is brilliantly written with a simple story. This sidebyside, shotforshot comparison is intended to illustrate the the unique vision of.
Comparison of both the 20 and 1974 film adaptions of f. Anyone seriously comparing the two films ought to have their head examined. Was born poor but then became rich and successful self educated and. The film stars robert redford in the title role of jay gatsby, along with mia farrow, sam waterston, bruce dern, karen black, scott wilson and lois chiles, with howard da silva. Gatsby obsessive jon reiner analyzes the liberties that baz luhrmann takes in adapting the novelwhat he gets right and what he gets. Nick first talks to gatsby during the first party he attends and doesnt realize it is gatsby he is talking to. Both the beautiful and damned and the great gatsby are novels about a male protagonists existential struggles and eventual downfall. There are many spoilers in the great gatsby book to movie comparison. Book versus movie adaptation gatsby obsessive jon reiner analyzes the liberties that baz luhrmann takes in adapting the novelwhat he gets right and what he gets wrong. Scott fitzgeralds the great gatsby tells the tale of a tangled web of love, lies, and liquor in the roaring 20s. Chapters 14 character analysis in 1974 film character analysis in 20 film character analysis in novel ch. Now, of course, i know different, although the car is gorgeous, and very iconic of the age. And it does have its redeeming qualities, especially in comparison to the 1974 version.
Scott fitzgeralds classic novel is quieter and less splashy than the more recent offering starring leonardo dicaprio, and its also more emotionally distant. The great gatsby compare and contrast book from 1974 movie. Critics and audiences generally complained about a lack of accuracy to the book and overall entertainment level, though the 1974 adaption is generally considered a good historical costume movie. In the past seven days, ive seen two film versions of the great gatsby.
Compare and contrast the great gatsby movie and movie. Scott fitzgerald that follows a cast of characters living in the fictional towns of west egg and east egg on prosperous long island in the summer of 1922. Do not just watch the movie instead of reading the book they are very different. How good is book compared to the film the great gatsby. The great gatsby is a 1974 american romantic drama film based on f. Since the book came out in 1925, there have been several filmed versions of the story. The 1974 version of the great gatsby sometimes referred to as the robert redford great gatsby was hollywoods second attempt at adapting the novel, and by all accounts everyone involved was working a lot harder to do the book justice. The1974 movie has strengths and weaknesses when comparing it. Comparing the movie the great gatsby and the book cram. Scott fitzgeralds work, but some were better than others. Since the book came out in 1925, there have been several filmed versions of.
Scott fitzgeralds novel, the great gatsby, and baz luhrmanns movie adaption can hardly be compared. The great gatsby similarities to the movie showing 2. I havent yet been able to see the 1974 version, yet, but i want to know what. We see gatsby s fancybutt house, his scrapbook of daisy paraphernalia, his monogrammed hairbrush, and a photograph of her on his vanity. For example, the details from gatsby in the book always throwing lavished parties that the neighborhood attended. In the book, fitzgerald makes it so that it is clear to the reader that daisy purposly ran her, over, that daisy noticed her but kept going because she knew of the affair, but in the movie, when the gatsby is telling nick carraway about what happened he emphasizes multiple time how it was an accident and daisy was stressed. Scott fitzgeralds the great gatsby follows jay gatsby, a man who orders his life around one desire. The truly great gatsbycomparison among 1974 motion. If youve read the book and seen the original, then continue on, please when nick carraway tobey maguire had grown frustrated with gatsby.
This book adaptation captures the feel and tone of f. When multiple movies are modeled after one of the most popular books in american literature, its fun to compare and contrast the films and see. The great gatsby book while the movie did remain loyal to the book at big times, it did skimp out on some other juicy details. The character has the same name in both the book and the movie. Scott fitzgerald, the great gatsby is a 1974 film directed by jack clayton, starring robert redford as the eponymous jay gatsby. The 1974 movie helped to pigeonhole gatsby in the canon of serious classical literature, aka it has to be boring to be a great work. It was directed by jack clayton and produced by david merrick from a screenplay by francis ford coppola. In this time we have seen a silent 1926 version now lost which, if we are to believe. A midwesterner becomes fascinated with his nouveau riche neighbor, who obsesses over his lost love. There were some others that were changed slightly, either for filming reasons or for careless from the director. With robert redford, mia farrow, bruce dern, karen black. Seems very confident, scary, looks right over nick, intimidating, gossipy ch. The great gatsby is a 1925 novel written by american author f.
It is also this quality which arguably makes gatsby the epitome of the unfilmable book. Okay, this will be my last question relating to the great gatsby, i promise. How would you compare the beautiful and damned with the. Wrapping it up as much as i found this movie a tonic to the woes of the luhrmann version, i cant recommend it too much.
The opening of 1974 s gatsby does a great job of introducing the story in a purely visual way. Shiring xing miss pruitt english 3 february, 20 the great gatsby comparison between book and 1974 movie the difference between the developing way of books and movies is magnificently huge because the way of emotion transmitting is different. In the 1974 film starring robert redford, the produces selected the right car, but from the much later 1920s, a 1928 rollsroyce phantom i. Ever since baz luhrmann announced that he was adapting f.
The great gatsbycomparison between 1974 movie and the book. Compare and contrast great gatsby movie vs book essays. Ok, then, lets compare the characters in the two great gatsby movies, head to head jay gatsby. The great gatsby comparison among book and 1974 film the difference between your developing technique of books and films is magnificently huge since the way of feelings transmitting differs. Actually, this is true of both the book and the film, but you cant exactly have nick unknowingly interacting with. The great gatsby 197420 sidebyside comparison youtube.
It must be analyzed and compared to our time in the late 1990s and early second millenia. It had a really large budget, brought in francis ford coppola to adapt the screenplay, and cast big name. Ive heard several different opinions on gatsby, thanks to social media, and so far, it sounds as though everyone enjoyed it. Fitzgeralds nick does refer to gatsby as the man who gives his name to this book emphasis mine, so the idea that the great gatsby is a text written by nick is not entirely original with. The great gatsby comparison between book and 1974 movie the difference between the developing way of books and movies is magnificently huge because the way of emotion transmitting is different. The great comparison of claytons and luhrmanns gatsby daily. The greater great gatsby the book the great gatsby has been depicted by lots of films, but the two that stand out the most are the 1974 and the 20 versions.
Differences between the great gatsby book vs movie page 2. The1974 movie has strengths and weaknesses when comparing it to the book as does the 20 version. We have a complete guide to each of the great gatsby movie adaptations, as well as some advice. The story primarily concerns the young and mysterious millionaire jay gatsby and his quixotic passion and obsession with the beautiful former debutante daisy buchanan. Scott fitzgeralds masterpiece involved a lot of big hollywood names, including robert redford, who starred as the title character, and francis ford coppola, who wrote the screenplay soon after completing work on the first of the godfather movies. There are some critics on the distaste for the music, but all in.
What makes fitzgeralds the great gatsby a classic novel is its utterly gorgeous prose. The great gatsbycomparison between 1974 movie and the. The great gatsby is a book that is very much expected to be made into a movie, and has been adapted several times before this one. In the case of the 1974 rendition of the great gatsby, the filmmakers tried to learn and adapt from previous attempts to made the book into a film.
When jay gatsby made it on the big screen in 1974, robert redford gave a performance true to the book, as a collected man of wealth. Like the directors other works, the great gatsby is noticeably, unmistakably luhrmanns and whether or not you believe in his vision is largely dependent on your tolerance of the mans idea of. It has been 5 years since daisy and gatsby have seen each other. I feel like every luhrmann film title should be prefaced with circus ring leaderesque embellishmentin the theaters this is a big deal, guys, the last time i went to a movie theater it cost four dollars, and then my mom asked me if i wanted to watch the. None of the movie versions of the book compared to f. The film also features mia farrow as daisy buchanan, sam waterston as nick carraway, bruce dern as tom buchanan, and karen black as myrtle wilson. I wonder what fitzgerald, whose prose was so graceful, so elegantly controlled, would have made of it. How does the 1974 film of the great gatsby compare to the. Whats the difference between the great gatsby the book and the great gatsby the movie. Baz luhrmanns movie the great gatsby versus the 1974 version with robert. My thoughts on the 1974 and 20 adaptations of the great gatsby. The great gatsby is a superficially beautiful hunk of a movie with nothing much in common with the spirit of f.
Scott fitzgeralds seminal book, it is almost impossible to have this discussion without addressing the other great. Scott fitzgeralds the great gatsbyand especially after he revealed that hed. Enjoys nicks company, acts like she knows all about gatsby, comforts nick, ignores. Similarities and differences between the great gatsby the. Robert redford and leonardo dicaprio as jay gatsby. Do not delve in if you want the film to be a surprise. The 1974 one with robert redford, the 2000 one with toby stephens, and the 20 one with leonardo dicap. This book is a classic not because critics revered its content, it is as great as it is because america embraced it. Differences between the great gatsby book vs movie page 1. I have read the book thrice and saw the 73 version when it came out.